CME "increased margin for the sixth time this round", silver plummeted and fell more than 40% in a week, reappearing the "historical top" model

# Source: Wall Street Insights

# By Bao Yilong

On February 5 local time, CME Group announced that it raised the initial margin requirement for its COMEX 100 Gold Futures from 8% to 9%, and hiked the initial margin ratio for its COMEX 5000 Silver Futures from 15% to 18%.

CME Raises Margins Again, Silver Breaks Below the $67 Mark

On February 5 local time, CME Group announced a hike in the initial margin requirement for its COMEX 100 Gold Futures from 8% to 9%, and an increase in the initial margin ratio for its COMEX 5000 Silver Futures from 15% to 18%.

During the Asian trading session on Friday, spot silver extended its sharp decline from the previous day, breaking through multiple integer mark levels in succession and slumping by over 5% intraday at one point. Spot gold also fell more than 1.5%, edging close to the $4,700 mark.

Spot silver has dropped by more than 40% from the all-time high hit on January 29 over the past week. Silver plummeted 19% on Thursday, erasing all its gains so far this year, with an unprecedented level of market volatility not seen since 1980.

As previously mentioned by Wall Street Insights, every silver market peak has been accompanied by historically key indicators such as consecutive and intensive margin hikes by exchanges. And in the current silver rally, CME has shown an extremely strong willingness to intervene with regulatory measures.

CME has raised margin requirements five times in a row in just the past month, a rarely seen frequency:

- December 12, 2025: Announced the first margin hike, raising the initial margin from $22,000 to $24,200.

- December 29, 2025: The second margin hike, with the initial margin increased from $24,200 to $25,000.

- December 31, 2025: The third margin hike with a larger magnitude, a sharp increase from $25,000 to $32,500.

- January 28, 2026: The fourth margin hike, switching to a percentage-based system, up from 9% to 11% (the high-risk category raised from 9.9% to 12.1%).

- January 31, 2026: The fifth margin hike with further increases, rising from 11% to 15% (the high-risk category up from 12.1% to 16.5%).

From a technical indicator perspective, silver is not yet in an "oversold" state for the time being.

(Silver 14-day Relative Strength Index)

Silver’s Major Peaks Are Not "Driven by Rallies", But "Strangled" by Regulation

Historically, silver’s sharp declines have never been due to "overbought prices", but an inevitable result of the collision between high volatility, high leverage and an abrupt regulatory brake.

The "sudden crash" in 1980 is the most representative case. On January 21 that year, the very day silver hit its all-time high, the New York Mercantile Exchange (COMEX) announced a "liquidation-only, new position ban" rule.

Prior to this, the exchange had raised margin requirements and tightened position limits multiple times. When long positions could no longer add leverage to drive up prices, the rally came to an abrupt halt — silver then plummeted 67% in the following four months.

The 2011 crash adopted a "boiling frog slowly" strategy. CME raised margin requirements five times in a phased manner over nine days. Though there was no one-off "sudden brake", the logic was the same: the cost of holding positions soared exponentially, leading to a capital chain collapse for long positions. Silver peaked after the second margin hike and fell 36% over 16 months.

Both crashes shared common characteristics:

1. Volatility surged to an extreme high, currently hitting 1,800% — a level that has remained below 200% for 93% of historical periods.

2. Valuation ratios became severely distorted, with the current silver-crude oil ratio breaking through 1.8, far exceeding the historical range of 0.2-0.5.

The key point is that a market peak is usually confirmed by a sudden change in rules. When exchanges force "deleveraging" by raising margin requirements, the frenzied long capital can no longer sustain the rally, and prices collapse like a building losing its support.

When the market evolves from orderly trading to a disorderly casino, regulation becomes the final straw that breaks the camel’s back.

## Risk Warning and Disclaimer

The market involves risks, and investment requires caution. This document does not constitute personal investment advice and has not taken into account the specific investment objectives, financial situation or needs of individual users. Users should consider whether any opinions, views or conclusions in this document are in line with their specific circumstances. Any investment made based on this document is at the investor’s own risk.